GLP-1 VS OTHER WEIGHT LOSS METHODS
How do medications like semaglutide and tirzepatide compare to diet, exercise, surgery, and other approaches? Here's an evidence-based breakdown.
AVERAGE WEIGHT LOSS BY METHOD
Diet + Exercise
5-10%
Semaglutide
15-20%
Tirzepatide
20-25%
Bariatric Surgery
25-35%
Based on clinical trial data. Individual results vary.
DETAILED COMPARISON
GLP-1s vs Diet & Exercise Alone
Diet & Exercise
- • Average 5-10% weight loss
- • High relapse rate (most regain)
- • No medication side effects
- • Builds sustainable habits
- • No ongoing cost (gym optional)
- • Requires significant willpower
GLP-1 Medications
- • Average 15-25% weight loss
- • Weight regain if stopped
- • Possible GI side effects
- • Reduces appetite naturally
- • Ongoing medication cost
- • Works with your biology
Bottom line: GLP-1s produce significantly more weight loss, but work best when combined with diet and exercise. The medication makes it easier to stick to healthy habits by reducing hunger and cravings.
GLP-1s vs Bariatric Surgery
Bariatric Surgery
- • 25-35% average weight loss
- • More durable long-term
- • One-time procedure
- • Surgical risks (1-2% complication)
- • Irreversible (most types)
- • Strict dietary requirements after
GLP-1 Medications
- • 15-25% average weight loss
- • Requires ongoing use
- • Non-invasive
- • GI side effects possible
- • Fully reversible (stop anytime)
- • No surgical recovery
Bottom line: Surgery produces more weight loss and is more durable, but GLP-1s offer significant results without the risks and permanence of surgery. Many patients try GLP-1s before considering surgery.
GLP-1s vs Other Weight Loss Medications
| Medication | Avg Weight Loss | How It Works |
|---|---|---|
| Semaglutide (Wegovy) | 15-20% | GLP-1 receptor agonist |
| Tirzepatide (Zepbound) | 20-25% | GLP-1 + GIP dual agonist |
| Phentermine | 5-10% | Appetite suppressant (stimulant) |
| Contrave | 5-8% | Naltrexone + bupropion |
| Orlistat (Alli) | 3-5% | Fat absorption blocker |
THE REAL QUESTION: SUSTAINABILITY
Every weight loss method has one thing in common: the challenge is keeping the weight off.
GLP-1 medications produce impressive results, but studies show most people regain weight after stopping. This isn't a failure of the medication—it reflects the biology of weight regulation.
Our approach at Moonshot focuses on two things:
1. Preserve Muscle
Rapid weight loss often means muscle loss. We use DEXA scans to track body composition and ensure you're losing fat, not muscle. Muscle preservation is critical for metabolic health and maintaining results.
2. Build Habits
The medication makes it easier to eat less. We help you use that window to build sustainable nutrition and exercise habits so you're not dependent on the medication forever.
GLP-1 WEIGHT LOSS AT MOONSHOT
Full Program
$405/mo
- • GLP-1 medication included
- • Medical oversight
- • Required labs & diagnostics
- • DEXA body composition tracking
- • Dosing adjustments
Prescription Only
$105/mo
- • Medical oversight
- • Rx sent to your pharmacy
- • Good if insurance covers GLP-1
- • Required labs & check-ins
- • Dosing guidance
COMMON QUESTIONS
Who is a good candidate for GLP-1 medications?
Generally, patients with BMI 30+ (or 27+ with weight-related conditions) who haven't achieved goals with diet and exercise alone. We evaluate each patient individually based on health history, labs, and goals.
What are the side effects of GLP-1 medications?
Most common are GI-related: nausea, constipation, diarrhea—especially when starting or increasing dose. These typically improve over time. We start with low doses and titrate slowly to minimize side effects.
Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide—which is better?
Tirzepatide (dual GLP-1/GIP agonist) shows slightly higher weight loss in trials, but both are effective. The best choice depends on individual response, side effects, and availability. We can discuss options during your consultation.
READY TO EXPLORE YOUR OPTIONS?
Start with a consultation. We'll review your health history and discuss whether GLP-1 therapy is right for you.
Book Consultation